Skip to Content

Individual Sopapilla Cheesecake

Individual Sopapilla Cheesecake bites – these hand-held pastries feature buttery, flaky cinnamon-sugar crust with a sweet cream cheese filling! These cute desserts are deliciously yummy!

Mini sopapilla cheesecakes dipped in cinnamon sugar ready for baking

Individual Sopapilla Cheesecake

I’m slightly obsessed with sopapilla cheesecake and I’m definitely crazy about all types of hand pies and empanadas so I decided to combine the two in these amazing individual sopapilla cheesecake pies!

The result is a bite sized pocket of cheesecake with a crispy, crunchy cinnamon crust.

It takes a little more effort to make than an individual pie (make my Puff Pastry Sopapilla Cheesecake if you’re looking for minimal prep), but it’s so worth the little bit of extra time!

They are totally adorable, and who doesn’t love a dessert you can eat on the go?

Additionally, they’re made with a few ingredients that you probably already have on hand!

Plate of 3 individual sopapilla cheesecake hand pies with one pie cut in half

How to Make Sopapilla Cheesecake Hand Pies

Start by beating cream cheese and sugar together along with some vanilla.

I like using Mexican vanilla because I think it has the best taste.

Set the cheesecake mixture aside while you cut out rounds of pie dough.

You can use pre-made refrigerated pie crust or from scratch.

The easy dough recipe from my Pineapple Empanadas would be perfect!

Making sopapilla cheesecake hand pies: Mini rounds of pie crust with a tablespoon of cream cheese filling in center

I like to use a small circle cutter for bite-sized pies.

The size of your cutter will determine how many empanadas you get.

I used the ring of a wide mouth canning jar which is about 3.5 inches wide. I got approximately 16 pies.

Fill the circle with a spoonful of the cream cheese mixture and fold over.

Don’t overfill or it will start to leak out as it bakes. Crimp the edges with a fork to seal.

Plate of 5 individual sopapilla cheesecake empanadas

To make the famous sopapilla topping, brush or dip the top of the pie in melted butter.

Next, sprinkle or dip in cinnamon sugar. I prefer to dip them, but it’s a little messier this way.

Do you have a grandma or family member who was famous for pies in your family?

My dad is the pie-maker in ours and he would sprinkle the scraps with cinnamon-sugar and bake it for us to eat.

These sopapilla cheesecake hand pies take me back to those days!

Except they’re better since they’re stuffed with cream cheese!

Check out these other great pies!

Fried guava empanadas with cream cheese. Everyone will love these dessert hand pies! #puertoricanfood

Pumpkin Hand Pies

Pumpkin Hand Pies with a crunchy cinnamon sugar topping!

Pumpkin Hand Pies